Page 24 - Shelter-October-2022
P. 24

THEME PAPER


              success of the  programme       can, at best, avail grants from   for public housing or site
              was attributed to substantial   government      programmes      and service schemes for the
              resources invested by the       or  small  loans  from  other   economically weaker section
              municipality;    terms     of   sources. The contention is      population or reserved  for
              lending favourable to the poor   that unless there are measures   the already existing squatter
              (short term,  demand based      to change the regulatory        settlements. All slums eligible
              loans); large demand for        framework, poor people will     for   tenure   regularization
              low cost financing; technical   not be able to graduate from    and    rehabilitation   were
              assistance through a network    the grey housing market.        classified as R-EWS (Nagpur
              of professionals managed by                                     Improvement Trust, 1987).
              the municipality, whose costs   Attempts in this direction      Such initiatives have been
              were included in the loans;     are  being  made  in  different   strengthened in Maharashtra
              and the role of the coalition   countries and cities, which     urban areas by the Unified
              of housing NGOs in putting      provide  a  basis  for  learning   Development  Control  and
              housing improvements for        and wider replication and       Promotion  Regulations  for
              low-income  households  on      regulatory    reform.     For   Maharashtra State - 2020, in
              the agenda of the municipal     example, ‘The City Statute’     which  regulations  specific
              government  and  nurturing      of  Brazil  has  a  provision   to the nature of existing
              the program through  its        for demarcating areas as        settlements apply in “Slum
              initial  growth phase (Ortiz    Special Social Interest Zones   Improvement           Zone”.
              and Zarate, 2006).              (ZIES) in Brazilian cities.     Reservations    for     small
                                              Declaration of an area as ZEIS   dwelling units/ plots have
              Reforming the  regulatory       regularizes  areas where the    been classified as “Inclusive
              framework                       process of occupation  has      Housing” in the Development
                                              occurred regardless of urban
              Examples world-wide show        planning norms  and allows      Control  Rules  (Government
              that institutional  finance for   the development of urban      of Maharashtra, 2020).
              incremental housing is more     regulations keeping in view  Enabling access to land
              effective  when  accompanied    the existing development,  and enhancing land tenure
              by measures that ensure         such as narrow streets and
              minimum norms of health         small plots. ZEIS is also used   security
              and safety, while at the same   for vacant land earmarked       BLC has made significant
              time keeping costs low. The     for  social  housing,  where  it   progress  because   public
              requirement of a sanctioned     has proved to be an effective   institutions have found it
              building plan  from local       instrument for making land      easier to deal with households
              government as a condition for   available  for  the  poor  in   with access to land for
              loan  sanction  is  expected  to   advantageous locations and   providing housing assistance
              ensure structural soundness     developing it with appropriate   (Kundu and Kumar, 2020). A
              and legality. However, most     affordable standards (Cities    point of concern is that the
              settlements  of the poor,       Alliance. 2010).                BLC component requires the
              including regularized slums,                                    possession  of tenured land
              unauthorized colonies and       The Development Plan for        as  a  pre-requisite  to  availing
              relocation   areas  do    not   Nagpur (1986-2011) included     funding assistance,  this in
              conform with development        a specific zone, ‘R-EWS Zone’   effect excludes the poorest
              control regulations, making     for the Economically Weaker     in towns and cities as they
              it impossible for building      Section population. The area    seldom have access to tenured
              plans to be sanctioned. They    in this zone was proposed       land (Mitra, 2021). On the


              22     HUDCO-HSMI Publication
   19   20   21   22   23   24   25   26   27   28   29