Page 62 - SHELTER
P. 62

POLICY REVIEW

                     TOWARDS AFFORDABILITY TO URBAN POOR


                                                             -Learnings from Dharavi and The World







                                             The  idea of slum redevelopment   visions.
           AR. SNEHAL SHIRISH                often comes  forward through
           GHAG                              projecting the inappropriateness  SLUM: AS AN
                                             of housing, infrastructure and    AFFORDABLE OPTION
                                             lack  of tenure security to  the
                                             slum dwellers by the concerned    According to  Alan Gilbert,
            Over the years, various          institutions. However, even though   the term ‘Slum’  is often found
            proposals and housing            it is a reality, it is also an affordable   interpreted as ‘dangerous’, as it
            solutions were put               option  for  the  urban poor,  where   opens up complex myths about
            forward by different             the land is available, accessible and   poor people. The World Bank had
            experts which had tried          becomes affordable in fulfilling  the   projected a scenario regarding
            to solve the problem of          everyday needs. The case of Dharavi   slums which explained how
            making cities slum-free,         demonstrates the example of slum   hundreds of millions of urban
            which are the larger level       formation by the urban poor over   poor in the developing world
            strategies that do not           the years for fulfilling the needs for   live  in  an  unsafe  environment
            acknowledge the urban            their livelihood which is based on   which creates threats to their
            poor on a deeper level.          small  scale  industries  that have a   health and security.  And these
            So, there is a need to           strong network within Dharavi  as   living environments  also  lack
            go deep down into the            well as within the city. The state has   basic infrastructure and services
            living pattern of Dharavi        taken the initiative of  making the   (Alan Gilbert, 2007) . However,
            residents. There is a need       ‘Dharavi redevelopment project’,   even though it is a reality, it
            to plug in the formal            a vision which aims to contribute   is  also  an  affordable option
            role of an NGO or NGOs           towards making Mumbai a ‘World    for the urban poor as  their
            to go on the deeper              Class City’,  which  has led to   struggle for obtaining everyday
            level understanding of           opposition  by the communities    needs  are associated  with the
            community needs and              residing in Dharavi along with the   spatial characteristics of slums.
            to gain the community’s          group of citizens. This paper focuses   Similarly,  during the 1900s
            trust.                           on how the city’s  ‘slum  policies’   people had  settled in Dharavi

                                             are endeavouring to untangle  the   in  search  of  affordable  shelter,
                                             problems  of  slum formation  in  the   either evicted by the state for
                                             city through examples of the world   various  reasons  or  encroached
                                             with a keen focus on Mumbai’s slum   for shelter and livelihood. Today,
          Keywords: urban poor, affordability,   Dharavi.    The paper endeavours   it is known as ‘slum’, where one
          slum,spatial dependencies          to think through the lens of urban   can notice every lane in Dharavi
                                                                               is developed in conjunction
          Ms. Snehal Shirish Ghag (snehalghag90@  poor and tries to establish thoughts   with their livelihood needs
          gmail.com)  is a practicing Architect and   on their sustainability  which are
          Urban Designer, Mumbai.            overlooked for building larger    and its urban form justifies the



          60      HUDCO-HSMI Publication
   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65   66   67