Page 78 - HUDCO-SHELTER-April22
P. 78

CASE STUDIES



              by people of Bondre Nagar.  CONCLUSION                          the context within which they
              The people have formed a co-    The current housing scenario    are situated.
              operative society and shown
              readiness to take a loan.  They   highlights  the    existing   SA advocates a balance of the
              have taken responsibility for   condition and implications      top-down and the bottom-
              their transit accommodation.    of the identified issues that   up approach; facilitators  of
                                              are detrimental to holistic     slum  rehabilitation  projects
                                              development  for the urban      should be working at all
                                              poor.  It enforces the need for   scales concurrently to adopt
                                              citywide approach to social     an informed and neutral
                                              housing that leverages  on      position.  Informed decisions
                                              the data collected to propose   based  on  the  principles  of
                                              holistic solutions for the urban   (1) data driven (2) inclusive
                                              poor.   The article provides a   approach     (3)     holistic
                                              detailed  on-ground  scenario   development         facilitate
                                              for affordable housing  in      impactful projects  where the
                                              the  city  of  Kolhapur  and    interests of the stakeholders
                                              highlights the issues (1) Loss   have been balanced.
              Way forward:                    of judicious use of land (2)    The citywide approach will
              In September 2021 the Project   Issues due to lack of holistic   ensure optimum utilisation
              proposal    was    submitted    development  (3)  Lack  of  an   of government land and an
              to the State government         inclusive planning approach.     inclusive planning approach
              for   approvals   and    after  The lack of comprehensive       beneficial for all concerned
              continuous     efforts,    an   data  available with the ULB    stakeholders.  The proposed
              important     milestone    of   makes it  difficult  to  take a   solutions have the potential
              land transfer in the name of    holistic  view  of  the  entire   to be replicated in similar
              the beneficiaries  has been     urban area.  This can lead to   2-tier and 3-tier cities willing
              achieved.  Once approvals       piecemeal slum rehabilitation   to implement social housing
              from the State and Central      projects which represent a      programs.
              government  are secured the     suboptimal use of the limited
              construction of the project     resources, such  as tenable     REFERENCES
              will commence.  The Bondre      land, and fail to leverage      (368-kolhapur.html ) : Census
              Nagar slum rehabilitation       an economy of scale.  It can    data  for  land  area  and
              project is on track to become   also lead to hesitancy by the   population
              a    precedent    for   other   ULB in undertaking slum
              rehabilitation  projects.   It  redevelopment projects due      https://shelter-associates.org
                                                                              : Shelter  Associates Website
              has the potential to give an    to complexities and conflicts   presenting spatial data at
              impetus to the citywide action   that  may    arise   during    citywide level
              plan and transform the lives of   planning.  The top-down
              the urban poor for the better.     and  non-inclusive  approach   https://pmay-urban.gov.
              The  vulnerable  settlements    implemented is ineffective      in/uploads/progress-pdfs/
              identified    through     the   and    slum     rehabilitation  PMAY_City_wise_for_web.
              research project can leverage   projects are often conceived    pdf :  Data  on number  of
              the learnings from Bondre       from   a   remote    position   projects sanctioned under
              Nagar.                          without any understanding of    PMAY


              76     HUDCO-HSMI Publication
   73   74   75   76   77   78   79   80   81   82   83