Page 43 - HUDCO-SHELTER-April22
P. 43

POLICY REVIEW


              into the implementation, it     the  Revenue  Administration    urban poor households in
              emerged that informality,       and the Urban Local Bodies      two select cities of Odisha,
              limited buoyancy in the real    (ULBs). Taking Odisha  as       as  well  as  in-depth  meetings
              estate market, and unsold       a  case,  this  paper  presents   and interviews with key
              housing    stocks    deterred   detailed      documentation     stakeholders  at  the  city  and
              large-scale  participation  of   of the processes required      state levels. It also draws upon
              private developers. Instead,    to obtain RoR and its           the documents published  by
              BLC emerged as the most         feasibility  as  the  ‘must  have’   GIZ India titled Unravelling
              successful vertical, breaking   documentary  evidence  for      the Interface between  Land
              the myth that urban poor do     accessing housing subsidies.    Administration Systems and
              not own land in cities.         To localise the understanding   Spatial  Planning  Processes:
                                              two cities of Berhampur         The Case of Odisha, India and
              One of the critical inputs      and Puri were selected in       Demystifying Urban Land
              to  access  the  support  for   Odisha.  This  paper  aims  to   Tenure Issues, The Curious
              housing         development     document the learnings from     Case of Small Cities in India,
              under BLC guidelines is the     Odisha for informing national   A Case Study from Odisha.
              ‘adequate documentation’ or     and state-level  schemes to
              the ‘Right’ papers as evidence   facilitate addressing housing   A REVIEW OF LAND
              for the land ownership. The     demand among the urban          MANAGEMENT
              majority of the States initially   poor segment, especially the   SYSTEMS IN ODISHA
              interpreted them as Record      economically weaker sections.   India follows a dual land
              of Right (RoR) that excluded                                    record keeping system (deed
              many     otherwise    eligible  APPROACH               AND      registration  system and the
              beneficiaries.  The success of  METHODOLOGY                     land revenue system of RoR).
              BLC in smaller and medium       The paper adopts a mixed-       The  co-existence  of  this  dual
              towns reinforces the fact that   method      approach      to   system makes maintenance
              poor in these cities do own                                     of clear and/or updated
              land albeit lack the adequate   understand     the    various   land records cost intensive,
              documentation to make their     typologies of land title and    inefficient to operate and
              claim. Many states addressed    land ownership documents        complicated to maintain. The
                                              available to the slum dwellers
              these barriers and simplified                                   presumptive titling system
              the processes to get the        of Odisha, the processes that is   without a robust updated
              ‘Right’ papers. To date, out of   required for accessing RoR in   spatial  database  subjects
              11 million houses approved      the state, and the innovations   land related transactions  to
              under the mission, over 70%     undertaken  by  the  state  to   litigations  thereby  hindering
              are approved under the BLC      facilitate  large scale uptake   the potential  for raising
              category (PMAY Data).           of the available BLC subsidy.   resources. The situation is
                                              The study involved field        particularly complex among
              Against this backdrop, it       research conducted in 2017-18,   urban poor dwellers.
              emerges that the provision      including continued dialogue
              of housing, especially  in      with urban slum households,     The land records in Odisha
              smaller and medium towns,       collecting   and    collating   have a measure of complexity
              can be resolved by forging an   relevant   land   documents     that  is not present in  any
              effective partnership between   from slum and non-slum          other   similar-sized   state.


                                                               April 2022 Volume 23 No. 1 - SHELTER     41
   38   39   40   41   42   43   44   45   46   47   48