Page 48 - HUDCO-SHELTER-April22
P. 48

POLICY REVIEW


              Purchase/Inheritance            governments  extend  leases/    amount of tenure security,
              through informal                provide possession certificates   and are threatened by natural
              transactions                    to these households. While      disasters, disease, and other
                                              they are not included for       risks on account of the lack
              Type of documents: Unregistered
              sale/partition deed             accessing housing subsidies,    of access to infrastructure,
                                              they are able to access basic   and poor living conditions.
              An unregistered sale deed can   services and infrastructure     At best, they possess some
              help establish the rights of the   on payment of a holding      sort   of   identity   proofs
              landholder  as a semi-formal    tax. For the households that    (Aadhar/Below        Poverty
              owner. It is a useful document   are connected to municipal     Line  (BPL)  cards)  that  make
              to show the transaction         infrastructure and pay the      them eligible for government
              between the  parties and        holding tax, the  holding       subsidies through the public
              the nature of possession.       tax receipt can serve as a      distribution system.
              However, it is an imperfect     possession/occupancy proof.     A process documentation
              title and cannot be used in the   In Puri, several households   is represented in Figure
              court of law to claim any legal   located on public land have   3  based  on  the  available
              right over the land/property.   legal   water    connections    land ownership typologies,
              Usually, the transaction is     provided  by the PHEO.          interviews   with    revenue
              carried out on an INR 10        Water    bills   issued   by    officials and local lawyers for
              (USD 0.15) non-judicial stamp   government       departments    acquiring the RoR.
              paper. The deed specifies the   are also evidentiary  proofs
              name of buyer and seller,       that establish occupancy for    Obtaining an RoR would
              description  of property (plot   a given time. The municipal    entail a complex process
              number, its area, construction   tax receipt has the name of    requiring anywhere between
              details),  amount  paid  by  the   assesse, ward number and the   6 months to 2 years. From
              buyer, etc., but is not registered   tax amount paid by the user,   the  field study, it has  been
              under the Registration  Act,    which includes the annual       observed that the relationship
              1908.                           charge imposed as holding       between the urban poor and
                                              tax, water tax, sanitation tax,   the revenue administration is
              Occupation      of    public/   street light tax, and drainage   disproportionately unequal.
              private  land  (not  in  conflict   tax.                        Revenue administration is
              with  environmental  zones/                                     mostly  dealing  with  de  jure
              planning reservations)          Occupation of land zoned for    rights of the land and the
                                              environmental     protection/
              Type of documents:  Possession/                                 urban poor finds it challenging
              Occupancy  certificate,  holding   reserved for other uses      to negotiate the maze of
              tax receipt                     Type of document: possession/   legalities.  Unlike ULBs where
                                              occupancy  certificate,  holding   Councillors play an important
              Occupation implies exercising   tax receipts                    role as a connect between the
              physical control of any land                                    municipal administration and
              by  an  individual/household,   Slums/informal settlements      the  communities,  revenue
              but not having any legitimate   that    are    located    on    administrations  do not have
              evidence    of    conveyance    environmentally    sensitive/   any such interfaces. The trust
              (purchase/inheritance/lease,    hazardous      land/reserved    between  the  communities
              etc.). Most of these households   land  are  considered  to  be   and revenue administration,
              are located on government       the most vulnerable. Such       to a large extent is missing. It
              land.    Sometimes,     local   households have the least       is perceived that the primary


              46     HUDCO-HSMI Publication
   43   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53